Political Support Grows following Mornington Peninsula Horse Welfare Protest

Mornington Peninsula, 29 April 2025 —
Support for community efforts to protect horses at a Mount Eliza property is gaining momentum, with local councillors and politicians now publicly backing calls for urgent intervention.

Following growing public concern over allegations of animal neglect, Kackeraboite Ward Councillor Stephen Batty, Paul Edbrooke MP, and Chris Crewther MP have all voiced support for the cause. It is understood that Paul Mercurio MP has also engaged with community members and Georgie Purcell from the Animal Justice Party has made a public statement in relation to the Mt Eliza horses.

Local Councillor Condemns ‘Total Neglect’

In a statement provided to STPL News, Councillor Stephen Batty said:

“I am extremely disappointed that this case of total neglect is allowed to continue…
There is no sense in locals continuing feeding these animals — they need to be moved…
I support the community in protesting outside this property in order to gain sufficient awareness to achieve the relocation of these animals.”

Paul Edbrooke MP: “This Is Sickening”

Paul Edbrooke MP, Member for Frankston, was the first state politician to speak out.

“I’m shocked at the images forwarded to me… There are no excuses for the state of the animals in the pictures which are so distressing I won’t share them online.”

Mr Edbrooke confirmed he had briefed relevant state ministers and encouraged community members to support the petition, now signed by more than 7,000 people.

Chris Crewther MP: “Attention Is Justified and Necessary”

Chris Crewther MP, who represents the state electorate of Mornington and has been contacted by numerous concerned residents, said he had been actively liaising with the RSPCA, Council, and others since Anzac Day.

Since being informed about these issues and allegations on Anzac Day (Friday), I’ve been in touch with the RSPCA, owner, Council/Mayor, and others. While I’m part of the State Opposition, my neighbouring MP (an MP in the Government) has also been in touch with the responsible State Labor Government Minister, and a contact of mine has had a walkthrough throughout the property in person on Sunday morning.

Crewther acknowledged the community’s frustration and confirmed he would meet with RSPCA staff on Thursday to raise concerns about both this case and broad

I note that the RSPCA have the legal authority (along with Council and Victoria Police) to investigate and take any action as required under the POCTA (Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) Act in Victoria, which itself is overseen by the State Labor Government, who also in part fund the RSPCA and their officers in Victoria.

At this stage, I understand that affected horses are being monitored on a managed programme by the RSPCA to bring them to full health and weight (which the RSPCA said can take a little while with underweight horses), with the last RSPCA visit being 4 April and the RSPCA again visiting yesterday. On the food aspect (noting of course there is much more to it than just food), RSPCA informed me that there is sufficient hay and water on site at the moment. This was also observed by my contact who walked the property, and through photos I have seen taken on the weekend. Also, another semi-truck load of hay I understand is arriving today.

Additionally, I’m meeting with two RSPCA staff members tomorrow (Thursday), and we’ll discuss this issue as well as the fact that RSPCA only have 26-28 officers across Victoria, under the State Labor Government, to deal with over 10,000 complaints of animal cruelty and to enforce the POCTA Act, being greatly insufficient.

I am hopeful that the attention brought to this matter will ensure any action, as necessary, and allowed for, under the Act. The RSPCA has powers of seizure if needed under the Act as well, if deemed necessary.

Rest assured that I’ll continue to follow up on this matter to hopefully achieve a positive outcome, in particular to ensure these horses are brought to full health and are guaranteed full ongoing care.”

Ongoing Investigation and Growing Pressure

RSPCA Victoria has confirmed an active investigation is underway and has reiterated that its inspectorate has legal powers to intervene under the Act.

A public statement released by RSPCA Victoria urged patience while inspectors work with the property owner, and cautioned against misinformation circulating on social media.

As political support increases, community members say they remain determined to keep the issue in public view until meaningful outcomes are achieved.

A Tragic Fall: Between Accountability and Isolation

In addition to her past as a horse breeder, Maxine Fraser is also a published author, having released a number of books on Amazon, including guides on horse handling and care. Her author profile offers a glimpse into a former life — one focused on structure, routine, and an apparent commitment to equine welfare.

A local resident who met Fraser around 15 years ago told STPL News:

“She struck me as quiet, intelligent. I never would have imagined things would end up like this.”

At some point, however, it appears the wheels fell off. Despite repeated offers of help over the years, it is understood Fraser refused support — clinging to the belief that a return to form was still possible.

“I’m not justifying any of what she’s done — she should never be allowed to care for a living creature again,” the source said. “But this is someone who is deeply troubled. Her fall from grace is extreme.”

Without assigning labels or making assumptions, the situation serves as a sobering reminder: cruelty must be stopped — but it often exists alongside deeper social failings, including prolonged isolation, unmet mental health needs, and a lack of community connection.

There is no undoing the suffering that has occurred — but in demanding justice, it is also worth reflecting on how we can prevent future tragedies by not letting people disappear behind fences.

STPL News will continue to provide updates as this story unfolds.