STPL News has published an interim snapshot of results from its ongoing Community State MP Feedback Survey, which invites residents to rate their local state representative’s performance during the current parliamentary term (2022–2026).
These results reflect a voluntary, self-selected survey and are not a scientific poll. Responses are being collected on an ongoing basis and the interim findings below may change as more residents take part.
Interim results as at: 25 February 2026
Take the survey:
Total responses so far
Total responses recorded: 496
- Mornington: 232 responses (46.8%)
- Hastings: 173 responses (34.9%)
- Frankston: 89 responses (17.9%)
- Nepean (closed): 2 responses (0.4%)
Residency note: One Mornington response indicated the respondent does not currently live in the electorate. That represents 0.4% of Mornington responses and 0.2% of total responses.
Interim Scorecard
This scorecard reflects recurring themes raised by respondents, including overall ratings patterns, reported electorate office responsiveness, visibility, and perceived delivery.
Grades are interim and may shift as the response pool grows.
Overall Grade by Electorate
- Mornington (Chris Crewther, Liberal Party): A
- Hastings (Paul Mercurio, Australian Labor Party): D+
- Frankston (Paul Edbrooke, Australian Labor Party): C
- Nepean: Not graded, survey closed until after the by-election result
Sub-Scores by Category
Mornington
- Overall sentiment: A
- Office responsiveness: A+
- Visibility and engagement: A
- Delivery and outcomes (perception): B+
Hastings
- Overall sentiment: D
- Office responsiveness: C
- Visibility and engagement: C+
- Delivery and outcomes (perception): D
Frankston
- Overall sentiment: C
- Office responsiveness: C
- Visibility and engagement: C
- Delivery and outcomes (perception): D+
Electorate Breakdown
HASTINGS GRADE: D+
Member: Paul Mercurio (Australian Labor Party)
Responses: 173 (34.9%)
Overall sentiment
Feedback in Hastings is strongly polarised but weighted negative overall. Ratings span from 0 to 10, with many clustered at the lower end and a smaller but vocal group rating highly.
Common criticisms raised
Recurring themes include:
- Perceived lack of tangible delivery
- Roads and infrastructure concerns
- Crime and safety
- Cost of living pressures
- Bus services and transport
- Concerns about office responsiveness
Some respondents alleged experiences such as being avoided or blocked after criticism. These are presented as claims made by respondents and are not independently verified in this interim summary.
Positive feedback
Supporters described:
- Strong community presence
- Support for local events
- Approachability
- Quick response times when contacted
- A perception of being a “local who supports locals”
Office responsiveness
Accounts vary:
- Some report same-week responses and resolved issues
- Others report no response or unresolved matters
Top priority issues
- Roads and transport
- Crime and safety
- Cost of living
- Housing
MORNINGTON GRADE: A
Member: Chris Crewther (Liberal Party)
Responses: 232 (46.8%)
Overall sentiment
Mornington responses are predominantly positive, with ratings clustering heavily at the higher end.
Common praise
Frequent themes include:
- Accessibility and responsiveness
- Direct community engagement
- Same-day responses
- Strong visibility at community events
- Personal follow-up on individual cases
Respondents referenced:
- Cross Peninsula bus services
- Planning overlays
- School advocacy
- Homelessness support
- Road safety concerns
Constructive criticism
Where concerns were raised, they focused on:
- A desire for stronger opposition accountability
- Wanting more forceful parliamentary presence
- Limits on tangible outcomes while in opposition
Office responsiveness
A consistent pattern of:
- Same-day responses
- Follow-up within a week
- High satisfaction ratings
Top priority issues
- Cost of living
- Housing
- Roads and transport
- Crime and safety
- Education
FRANKSTON GRADE: C
Member: Paul Edbrooke (Australian Labor Party)
Responses: 89 (17.9%)
Overall sentiment
Frankston feedback is mixed but leaning negative based on interim responses and ratings patterns.
Common criticisms
Recurring concerns include:
- Perceived lack of communication
- Office unresponsiveness
- Photo opportunities without follow-through
- Crime and affordability pressures
Some respondents linked dissatisfaction to broader state government performance. These comments reflect respondent views.
Positive feedback
Supporters cited:
- Long-term infrastructure changes
- School and health upgrades
- Responsiveness when personally contacted
- Contribution to improving Frankston’s image
Office responsiveness
Reports were highly variable:
- Some report no response
- Others report within-week resolution
Top priority issues
- Housing
- Cost of living
- Crime and safety
- Education
- Health
NEPEAN (Closed)
Responses recorded: 2 (0.4%)
Nepean remains closed until after the by-election result. Two responses were received despite closure. These will not be formally reported until the by-election concludes.
Cross-Electorate Trends
Across Hastings, Mornington and Frankston, the most frequently raised issues are:
- Roads and transport
- Cost of living
- Housing
- Crime and safety
- Health and education
A recurring theme across all electorates is the importance of electorate office responsiveness, perceived visibility versus delivery, and whether MPs are seen to prioritise community needs over party alignment.
Have Your Say
Residents in Hastings, Mornington and Frankston can take part in the ongoing survey via the STPL News form:
Further interim updates will be published as additional responses are received.
Support Independent Local Journalism
This is what independent local journalism looks like when it does its job. If you value reporting that is not dependent on access, approval, donors, or corporate backing, please support STPL News.
